Showing posts with label Society. Show all posts

Seeing the Monster Within Ourselves

No Comments »

Today was a sad day for all Pakistanis. More than four decades ago, Pakistan lost half of its population to a new country. Today we were struck by a different kind of calamity. An army school in Peshawar echoed with deafening roar of AK-47 firing. The targets were children. The killers were barbarians.

More than anything else, the news made me think about how even such an act can be humanly possible. True, wars have brought the worst in people across cultures -armies have countless times in the past decimated populations, torched food supplies and crops, raped women and children and plundered and razed entire cities. History of us humans is no stranger to savagery. But then, humanity moved ahead. We learnt to value peace and civilized living. The fruits of peaceful coexistence were for all to see and enjoy. A part of me wants to think that we gave up our vicious instincts to inflict senseless pain to our enemies.

The force in our hands have been becoming deadlier. I imagine holding an AK-47 -havingan infinite power to bring death around myself; being the sole judge of who deserves to live; sparing a few lives when my heart feels soft. 

But then I also think about having a 14 year old  target locked. How can any part of my entire existence let me proceed with it? How can even dare move my finger on the trigger? A helpless, scared, fourteen year old. A boy I do not even know.

And yet 132 times the trigger was pressed. Classmates watched each other falling; silence replaced their shrills; and mutilated caricatures stared back at their former friends.

I also think about what would be going on in the children's minds as they left us for a better world. Was it about how to tuck his best friend in so the terrorist take him for the dead? Or was he weaving a safe story to give his mom when she asks what he has been up to? May be he just took comfort in the thought that it is all a bad dream. After all, why would fully armed terrorists ever get into his classroom and shoot at all his friends?

To know that people this perverse, sick and dastard share this land with us is disturbing. As unfathomable as this is, we cannot go back from here in denial. Yes, humans walk this Earth who are capable of shedding blood of 132 innocent children in  vain in front of their best friends. Yes, they live among us, either in our own very country, or somehow connected to our people. They communicate with us through tweets, Facebook and TV. These are real human beings, who are born to mothers and may be even loved by some. Somehow, somewhere, somthing has gone awefully wrong, for humanity cannot have allowed it.

Denial in the face of severe grief and shock is understandable. We may find people among ourselves saying that such people are not humans. As inhumane as the acts are, they were committed by humans. Even animals would shy from such henious atrocities.

We also get to hear that such acts cannot be committed by Muslims. It is impossible to find out the faiths of the attackers. To me, the fact that such inhumane acts can even be carried out makes their actual faith completely meaningless. Nevertheless, these attacks were later claimed by an organization that professes not just to be Muslims, but in fact champions of Islam.

'Being a Muslim' is distinct from 'Acting in accordance with Islam'. Being a Muslim is an identity that connects one to the greater community of people of Islamic faith. In  Pakistan, we also have a legal definition for a Muslim. So are Taliban Muslims? I opine that, yes, very much so. Have they been acting in accordance with Islam? Clearly and outrightly, No!

It is understandable to distance oneself from people who have committed henious crimes of unthinkable scale. We all do it to reiterate our own commitment to staying civilized. That is perhaps what leads us to conclude that such people cannot be Muslims.

But beyond such denial should follow realization. That yes, people like us -Muslims, Pakistanis and sons of this soil, have committed such grave crimes against humanity. We should do so not because the blood is on our hands, but because the solution is. This realization would most definitely follow an introspection, which would lead to rethink the way we interpret our religion and  the way we educate our coming generation. The menace of terror that we face arises from a thought discourse that is very much ours. We need to rethink it so that extremist views are not encouraged.. These people are no aliens. Courage requires that we are able see the monsters in our own selves.

'Hey! I Have Read 'Rich Dad; Poor Dad' Too!

No Comments »


This is a 60 minute documentary series by the BBC -one of the surviving bastions of true journalism in my opinion. It tells the story of those behind and in front desk of a growing economy of knowledge training and 'wealth skills'. In true journalistic fashion, it retells the story as it is for the trainers ,the average Joe consumers and those who truly did become wealthy by using the mantra.

The Book 'Rich Dad; Poor Dad' sits in the centerstage of many of the wealth training aficandos. It is read with fanatic zeal that borders on the religious reverance. Halfway through the documentary did I remember, I have read the book too! I did it when I was 18 or so, and I remember clearly being impressed by the ideas. So much so that I rung up my best friend and asked him to read it. Then, even more strangely, I drove to his house and dropped off the book. Needless to say given the usual friends I have, he did not read it.

Why was I so impressed by the book? Perhaps because it validated what I have seen and been taught by people around me. My dad was a true entrepreneur, and like many of the 'wealth experts' that rake millions in speaker fee, he somewhat even despise being 'too educated'. This contrasted with what I saw at school. Every other kid was preoccupied with education, grades and career, as early as end of O Level's.

So this book did give a lot of credance to the idea that moneymaking goes best when uninhibited by preoccupation with being in office jobs. I have been seeing it since childhood.

But now, when I see this video after having completed my formal education in a medical school I see a different picture.

I see the speakers luring people into paying heavy fee (definitively; upfront), by showing them a prospects of a luxury living (mere prospect; distant).

The main market of such trainers are people disenchanted by the standard education model (middle school, high school, college). Getting wealthy will always be something everyone will desire, and working for it will be something everyone will despise. But this model seems to have narrowed down on a demographic that would likely bring the maximum revenue.

There can be two reasons for someone to struggle in school. Either A: the schooling does not bring in their best potential, or B: they do not have the neccessary talent/capabilities to excel in school. The speakers want people to believe, that the reason they sucked at school, is never option B.

I am absolutely certain that they are being dishonest about it. They do not want to push away potential audience by telling them to build more talents or capacities. They instead want to validate people in their beliefs and use it to fund their own spree of fanciful training sessions across the country.

Many of the core wisdoms are true financial maxims. Every person, top scorer or school dropout, must understand them and be financially informed. The only way a healthy financial education discourse can replace the existing dichotomy between 'book-wise' and 'money-wise' is to take it back to schools, and have a solid curriculum in financial education included. Schools and their curricula are monitored and are accountable. They have to respond to changes in society and markets. They ahve to remain truthful and honest. Financial gurus do not run their shops primarily for the interest of the population. They have to fund themselves foremost, and as part of their aura of success, have to do it by living it large.

Let's take it back to schools. Make them more accessible and open, and their curricula more robust and inclusive. That is what should be making the next generation of millionaires.

     

Should you support or not support the youtube ban?

1 Comment »

Its two months since YouTube –the world’s biggest video junction, is banned from Pakistan. Two months ago, a shoddy movie depicting Muhammad (SAW), the Prophet of Islam in a derogatory way was popularized on YouTube. Later, the producer was found to have conned the artists and studio owners into working on the said movie. Later still, the producer was jailed for fraud.

The whole affair was a disgusting sham. The ploy worked, and thousands of Pakistanis came on streets, while hooligans looted and committed acts of arson. The government then decided to block YouTube until the website removes the sacrilegious movie or at least make it unavailable in Pakistan.

Google usually does that. It blocked access to certain pages on YouTube’s website in other countries where the content was deemed inappropriate, like India and Bangladesh. But it did not do it for Pakistan. So, as the said content remain available, whole YouTube remained, and still remains blocked throughout Pakistan.

I have my reasons to believe our government and its officials has little interest in religion. Neither do they base their decisions on Islam. In fact, it can be argued they are not even remotely sincere to the cause of Islam. Yet, they cite religious reasons to press on the ban on the entire YouTube –which has millions of videos on thousands of different topics including a treasure trove of Islamic videos, when clearly the ban is not even serving the religion.

Rather, I believe that the government apparatus is only keen on suppressing avenues of free speech and whistle blowing which are widely accessible to the general public. Already, YouTube videos have exposed influential media public figures and business tycoons. They regularly lambast political bigwigs, and recently, they have been instrumental in getting the word out to the world from rebellions in Syria and wider Middle East. Government of Pakistan feels much more in charge without such a wayward avenue which was fast becoming part of the mainstream media. The mushrooming growth of broadband connectivity in the last decade  have made Internet videos a potent tool at the hands of anonymous reporters and political activists.

The government could not have cited a more indisputable reason to take down Internet media. There is legitimate anger at the small group of miscreants who initiated this devious ploy of instilling unrest in the Muslim world. However, we need to ask ourselves who are we really empowering by banning the entire YouTube. Can the people at the helm of this decision can really be trusted for their sincerity to Islam? Aren’t we making the tyrant rulers stronger by suffocating free media? Are we also not surrendering a very powerful tool to bring down injustice at the orders of these very people who propagate these injustices?

I feel that this debate needs to be taken up in the national discourse. Rather than having a small fanatical pressure group pressing the government, and the government only too happily blocking access to free information, we need to have a more mainstream debate based on reasoning and keeping in view the immense contribution of YouTube to Pakistani society, politics and even religion.

Failure and the Need to Tackle its Challenge

No Comments »


Failure must be viewed as any significant compromise of the full functioning of a system. The compromise doesn't have to be absolute to merit being called a failure. Any compromise that takes the level of function below any perceived 'minimum passable grade' should be called a failure.

I have noticed that Pakistanis have a general unwillingness to improve on a failed function. Rather, they treat it as a given conditionality. In short, they believe and give the impression that such reduced level of function is in fact the 'natural' level of functionality.

Firstly, a prevelant definition of failure equates it with total disaster and loss of all function. Hence, a dilapidated school education system would still not be deemed 'failed' until it completely stops imparting services.

Second is perhaps a natural response to any challenge. When we face a challenge, we are facing a choice between either tackling it, or mending our ways and complying. Usually, we would tackle when we think that the challenge is surmountable, that we are strong, and that the complications of a failed attempts are small. If the challenges is too big to tackle, or if we are not strong enough, or if we deem tackling too risky, we mend our ways and comply.

Failure looms as a challenge in front of us all. However, probably since we are so demoralized, we tend to overly weigh factors that favor compliance. So we have developed our own science of profitable mending of our ways so as to not tackle the challenge.

The government functionaries are a good example. They pose several challenges including inefficiency,  cumbersome processes,  and lack of modernity. But there are also innovative ways of hoodwinkng this creaking system, with options including political pressure, corruption, shuffling personnel and using archiac laws. In the end, someone who is willing enough will get things done, but the larger willingness on part of the wider public to make the process smoother remains missing. This chronic deficiency of a critical element -the larger desire to avoid failure -remains a key detriment to the progress of a genuinely Pakistani development culture. 

Polio Does Not Do Politics

Read more » | No Comments »

 

Polio immunization campaigns, despite registering landmark successes worldwide in Pakistan, have come under fire in a military conflict in North Western Pakistan. Last year, American Intelligence recruited Hep B Vaccination teams in its hunt for OBL. Taliban commanders, holding sway over large tracts of tribal belts, have recently outlawed access to children for polio immunization teams. Later, Tribal jirga (assembly) echoed the sentiments of Taliban commanders and put directed tribal populations to refrain from having children immunized. On 19th July 2012, an expat physician came under fire while moving in his UN marked vehicle in Karachi for an immunization drive.

YDA Strike 2012–The Events, Results and Conclusions

Read more » | No Comments »

The Young Doctors' Association Punjab strike lasted for almost 3 weeks and left in its wake 1000's of patients deprived of rightful medical care. Amid media reports of clash, chaos, deaths and police actions, the strike was eventually called off on the 9th of July 2012, without the original YDA demand for a service structure adequately

Passion for Pakistan: The Mystic Journey to True Development

Read more » | No Comments »

 

Pakistan has a mystical glory to it. An elusive spirit –indefinable and intoxicating; one that waits to be dispelled, but still lingers. It has defied conquerors, stood its many masters and provided for millions who poured on to it. A country like no other in multitudes of ways –it’s a paradise for a geologist, an enigma for anthropologist, a delight for a trader, and a true treasure for an archeologist.

Table Tennis Remains the Pariah of Commercial Sport (to my dismay)

Read more » | No Comments »

Table Tennis is one of the most remarkable sports ever. It’s easy to learn, agile, reflexive and immensely enjoyable. That makes it popular too –the Table Tennis table can be found everywhere from schools to colleges, workplaces, common rooms and homes around the world. The number of people who play it makes table tennis one of the most popular games in the world, even surpassing soccer. But, I would ask: is it really a proper sport?

The Barricades to Our Rightful Anger

Read more » | No Comments »


At twelve noon, I kept my car to the left as I slogged past the Dr. Ziauddin Ahmed Rd. intersection over to MT Khan Road. Driving from the Club Road end, I now have to drive an extra 100 meters to make a turn towards Clifton, thanks to a new security arrangement for the Chief Minister House. This extra 100 meters portends a dark turn for my generally jovial mood, for I, along with a plethora of lorries, rickshaws, motor bikers and water tankers get funneled into a kinky and narrow lane lined on both sides by parked sedans, at instances doubly parked, and dutifully attended by their reclining drivers.

The Blind Man and the Arrogant City

No Comments »

 

clip_image002

I had a very moving encounter with a visually impaired old man who came to Civil Hospital Karachi. I was walking back to my campus with a colleague, absorbed in a conversation about an ongoing research project when we passed within shouting distance of him. My black polarized sunglasses put him at my retinal blind spot, but my female colleague had to cut short my monologue for his desperate calls. The man was calling out for directions to anyone who would care to explain the scribbling on a small paper he was clutching.

Over a broad consensus, the old man’s hand was given into mine and I was directed to take him to his destiny –the cardiology OPD at CHK. He must be in his seventies and had a hoarse voice, weak stature but a steady gait. Hand in hand we started walking against throngs of people walking in every direction, seemingly more against us, at a slow, laboring pace.

My ability to get around crowds was suddenly neutralized. My partner held my hand and kept walking in a straight line. The crowd on the other hand reminded me of the kinetic model of gaseous particles I was taught in high school –crisscrossing, bumping, stopping and turning in every direction. If I were alone, I wouldn’t have a problem making repeated adjustments to avoid the incoming people. But sadly my blind man wouldn’t see the chaos.

So people were bumping and rubbing past him at the face of my amazed stares. I had assumed that a blind man would have a problem of bumping into people on walkways, but here I was seeing people bumping into him head on!

The pedestrians were not the only ones up against our faces. One motorcyclist streaked past his shirt and tore his side pocket. The blind man was furious and so was I, he being more verbally expressive while me being dumbstruck.

Soon I realized that the low lying topography of Civil Hospital needs careful mapping for him. I kept telling him to ‘step up, now step down, now be careful, don’t splash water’ while he dutifully followed. For him this was usual, but he appreciated my keenness. Navigation is my weak side too, so I asked a couple of people before I was finally at the cardiac OPD (Civil is like level 10 of a maze puzzle).

The doctor examined him and wrote him his prescription and refilled the drugs. I hope that somebody at his place will be able to administer him those. I was relieved to have done my duty and asked the doctor if I can leave. The doctor looks up and asks me: ‘Are you not his attendant?’

And I thought, ‘Am I?’

He only met me near the campus; so how did he get here in the first place?

May be his attendant will be picking him up from somewhere. I asked him that, and his reply still leaves me in awe of human dignity and courage:

‘Allah brought me here’ –though the symbolism was completely lost on him.

He has no son or anybody to come with him at this age. He took a bus to come from Malir, a neighborhood we also metaphorically refer for a place that is very far away. Not to mention he is on cardiac medications.

The bus ride I later realized was no short of Jihad itself. I walked him to the bus stop on the main road –the perils only magnifying here. Motorists seem not to realize that 2.7% of Pakistan’s population suffers from some forms of visual impairment. With my heart in my mouth I leapt forward to stop one car trying to park –the footpaths being already taken by vendors. In our zeal to beat the clock and the system, we seem to have forgotten that if not blindness, old age does afflict everyone.

The first bus conductor to respond to our wave apologized. Understandably, he wasn’t prepared to make arrangements in his small bus with its filled seats to take him home. Once again, the old man did not care. We waited for another one. Thank God, this time my patience was not tested. The bus had a vacant seat and I was really happy that finally he’ll be on his way home. We carefully got on the bus and I seated him. I told his fellow passenger that he has to go to Malir, still in disbelief as to how a man of this age and impairment can make it from there.

With a sigh of relief, I got off and disappeared. May be I was too embarrassed at the treatment meted out to him by my own fellow countrymen, or maybe I was so rushed that I forgot to pay him my due respects.

 

The above post by the author was published in the Medicalopedia Blog on the theme of Medical Ethics

The Analog OneNote–That beats Microsoft Hands-down

Read more » | No Comments »

After using Outlook, PDAs, task management softwares, reminders and syncing, I finally stumbled upon this great innovation of the bygone era. Not just serendipity, its about managing life without the techie fuss, naturally

Given my peculiar habit of instantly forgetting stuff as soon as they go out of my sight, I have been mightily concerned about keeping all things in my visual axis. Keeping things in order has been my lifeline –not long after my obsession with order wanes, I start losing my precious possessions like phone, steth, pens, wallet, pen, and ID documents,  while not mentioning the utter chaos it brings to my studies and hobbies.

The Tomb of Benazir Bhutto –Jewel of the Queen of Sind

Read more » | No Comments »

The Benazir Tomb is a prodigious white structure that stands majestically amidst vast expanses of wheat fields in the heart of rural Sind. Visible from miles, the tomb’s imposing sight greets zaaireen (the visitors) and wayfarers alike as they travel on the main thoroughfare from Larkana. Glistening brilliantly under the intense sun of upper Sind, the great arched domes of the monument seem to be counting days they can stand untarnished by effects of climate and dust: the heat seems to have bleached rest of the landscape of color, except for the lush green of the wheat fields.

clip_image002

Being a Doctor in a New Country –the Social Transition

Read more » | No Comments »

Medical careers are getting increasingly internationalized for young graduates around the world. The list of countries with opportunities for international graduates on offer is expanding fast. Every week comes with news about Board Exams and Certifications in different countries and how it is improving and evolving. It appears less of a problem for countries to assimilate international workforce into their healthcare. But how big is the issue of assimilation into a new country for the international graduates themselves?

How CIA Games Hampers the Drive to End Polio in Northern Pakistan

Read more » | No Comments »

13th of April 2011, I was made part of a WHO team to monitor effectiveness of community vaccination drive carried in different districts of Karachi. i spent the day with my team visiting a set of clusters in the Baldia Town of Karachi.

At the cost of sounding alarmist, I’d regard it as my firsthand experience of observing the enormity of a community vaccination in Pakistan –it almost felt undoable. I was seeing the face of Karachi I have never seen before -rural, ethnic, rugged and a whole lot more like Afghanistan on CNN.

(C) Copyrights Reserved by Hasan Iftikhar. Powered by Blogger.